Results for loop.test.sh

statusdashbashmkshzshosh
pass 1313141317
ok 24121
N-I 10000
BUG 21330
total1818181818
casedashbashmkshzshoshdescription
0pass pass pass pass pass implicit for loop
1pass pass pass pass pass empty for loop (has "in")
2pass ok ok BUG pass for loop with invalid identifier
detailsdetailsdetails
3pass pass pass pass pass Tilde expansion within for loop
4N-I pass pass pass pass Brace Expansion within Array
details
5pass pass pass pass pass using loop var outside loop
6pass pass pass pass pass continue
7pass pass pass pass pass break
8pass pass pass pass ok dynamic control flow (KNOWN INCOMPATIBILITY)
details
9pass pass pass pass pass while in while condition
10pass pass pass pass pass while in pipe
11pass pass pass pass pass while in pipe with subshell
12pass pass pass pass pass until loop
13pass pass pass ok pass continue at top level
details
14ok ok BUG ok pass continue in subshell
detailsdetailsdetailsdetails
15BUG BUG BUG BUG pass continue in subshell aborts with errexit
detailsdetailsdetailsdetails
16ok ok pass pass pass bad arg to break
detailsdetails
17BUG ok BUG BUG pass too many args to continue
detailsdetailsdetailsdetails
70 passed, 10 OK, 1 not implemented, 9 BUG, 0 failed, 0 timeouts, 0 cases skipped

Details on runs that didn't PASS

bash2 for loop with invalid identifier

stdout: 
stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 3: `-': not a valid identifier

mksh2 for loop with invalid identifier


stdout: 


stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/mksh: <stdin>[1]: for: bad identifier

zsh2 for loop with invalid identifier


stdout: 


hi

stderr: 


zsh: parse error near `-'
zsh: parse error near `done'

dash4 Brace Expansion within Array


stdout: 


-{a,b}
{c,d}-

stderr: 


osh8 dynamic control flow (KNOWN INCOMPATIBILITY)


stdout: 


1
2
3

stderr: 


    $b
    ^~
[ stdin ]:4: 'break' not found
    $b
    ^~
[ stdin ]:4: 'break' not found
    $b
    ^~
[ stdin ]:4: 'break' not found

zsh13 continue at top level


stdout: 


one

stderr: 


continue: not in while, until, select, or repeat loop

dash14 continue in subshell


stdout: 


> 1
subshell status=0
. 1
> 2
subshell status=0
. 2

stderr: 


bash14 continue in subshell


stdout: 


> 1
subshell status=0
. 1
> 2
subshell status=0
. 2

stderr: 


mksh14 continue in subshell


stdout: 


> 1
Should not print
subshell status=0
. 1
> 2
Should not print
subshell status=0
. 2

stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/mksh: <stdin>[6]: continue: can't continue
/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/mksh: <stdin>[6]: continue: can't continue

zsh14 continue in subshell


stdout: 


> 1
subshell status=0
. 1
> 2
subshell status=0
. 2

stderr: 


dash15 continue in subshell aborts with errexit


stdout: 


> 1
should fail after subshell
. 1
> 2
should fail after subshell
. 2

stderr: 


bash15 continue in subshell aborts with errexit


stdout: 


> 1
should fail after subshell
. 1
> 2
should fail after subshell
. 2

stderr: 


mksh15 continue in subshell aborts with errexit


stdout: 


> 1
Should not print
should fail after subshell
. 1
> 2
Should not print
should fail after subshell
. 2

stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/mksh: <stdin>[7]: continue: can't continue
/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/mksh: <stdin>[7]: continue: can't continue

zsh15 continue in subshell aborts with errexit


stdout: 


> 1
should fail after subshell
. 1
> 2
should fail after subshell
. 2

stderr: 


dash16 bad arg to break


stdout: 


hi

stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/dash: 4: break: Illegal number: oops

bash16 bad arg to break


stdout: 


hi

stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 4: break: oops: numeric argument required

dash17 too many args to continue


stdout: 


a
b
c
--

stderr: 


bash17 too many args to continue


stdout: 


a
--

stderr: 


/home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 3: continue: too many arguments

mksh17 too many args to continue


stdout: 


a
b
c
--

stderr: 


zsh17 too many args to continue


stdout: 


a
b
c
--

stderr: 


continue: too many arguments
continue: too many arguments
continue: too many arguments