Warning: Work in progress! Leave feedback on Zulip or Github if you'd like this doc to be updated.

List of Errors in the OSH Interpreter

Table of Contents
Syntax Errors in Oil String Literals
Fatal vs. Non-Fatal
Strict Modes
Parse Error API
Runtime Error API: error codes + error contexts?
Problem in bash: Context affects a lot
Arith Eval
Bool Eval
Word Eval
Command Exec
Syscall Failures
Interpreter Failures
Runtime Parse Errors
Parse Time Errors

Parse Error: Can be determined statically spec/parse-errors.test.sh

TODO: See test/runtime-errors.sh. Merge them here.

Syntax Errors in Oil String Literals

Fatal vs. Non-Fatal

Fatal Error: terminates the interpreter unconditionally, e.g. divide by zero does this in bash.

Non-fatal error: terminates the current builtin and exits 1

non-fatal errors can be turned into fatal errors.

by Strict modes: set -o errexit

strict modes can also things that are not errors at all into fatal errors set -o nounset set -o failglob

Fatal errors can be turned into non-fatal ones!!!!

by dparen:

(( 1 / 0 ))

by command sub -- although this involves another process so it's understandable!

set -o errexit echo $(exit 1)

Strict Modes

strict_array strict_errexit strict_arith

TODO: strict-word-eval? for unicode errors for subshell negative indices? I think this is most consistent right now.

Parse Error API


p_die() internally

w = w_parser.ReadWord()
if w is None:
  do something with w_parser.Error()

Related to memory management API:

# arena is the out param
arena = pool.NewArena()
c_parser = cmd_parse.CommandParser(w_parser, arena)
bool ok = c_parser.Parse()
if ok:
  arena.RootNode() #  turns indexes into pointers?
  arena.Deallocate()  # d
  c_parser.Error()  # Is this still a stack?

Runtime Error API: error codes + error contexts?


List of contexts:

Problem in bash: Context affects a lot

echo $(( 1 / 0 )) echo 'after-$(()) (( 1 / 0 )) echo 'after-$(())

Arith Eval

Divide by zero: $(( 1 / 0 ))


Maybe: integer overflow. But we want big numbers.

Type errors between integers and strings:

$(( x * 2 ))  # doesn't make sense, except in bash's crazy world.

Invalid hex constant:

echo $(( x * 2 ))   (fatal in bash)

Bool Eval

regcomp parse error:

x=$(cat invalid-syntax.txt) [[ foo =~ $x ]]

Word Eval

IMPORTANT: Command sub error $(exit 1)

User-requested error: ${undef?error}

set -o nounset

def _EmptyStrOrError(self, val, token=None):
  # calls `e_die()`

Variants: nounset: index out of bounds ${a[3]} I guess same diagnostic?

In bash you can set an index out of bounds, like b[2]=9
Might want to have a mode for this?

set -o failglob TODO: not implemented might need PWD diagnostic

Redirects: Redirect to empty filename/descriptor ( or array)

{ break; }
^~~~~~ break only invalid inside loop, etc.


Command Exec

IMPORTANT: subshell error ( exit 1 )

set -o errexit -- turns NON-FATAL error into FATAL error.

set -o pipefail pipefail might need some fanciness for ${PIPESTATUS}

Trying to set readonly variable: readonly foo=bar foo=x (could any of this be done at compile time?)

Trying to redeclare a variable? That can also be parse time. local x=1 local x=2

Type errors between Str and StrArray: -- strict-array controls this EvalWordToString calls e_die()`

echo foo > "$@" ^-- # Should have what it evaluated to? # This could be static too

case "$@" in "$@") echo bad;; esac

${undef:-"$@"} is OK, but ${var%"$@"} doesn't make sense really. ${v/"$@"/"$@"}

LHS evaluation: s='abc' s[1]=X # invalid because it's a string, not an array

Invalid descriptor:

fd=$(cat invalid.txt) echo foo 2>& $fd


In core/builtins.py:

return 1

A usage error is a runtime error that results in the builtin returning 1.

Builtin has too many arguments -- but this falls under the errexit rule cd foo bar baz continue "$@" (Parse error: continue 1 2 3)

Although we might want to highlight the extra args.

Syscall Failures

Fatal error from system calls: fork() could fail in theory

Some are not failures:

stat() [[ -f /tmp/foo ]] 
cd /ff  chdir()  # exit code 1
cat <nonexistent  # This is just exit code 1 

Interpreter Failures

Runtime: Stack Too Deep (catch infinite recursion) Out of memory: should not happen with OSH, but maybe with Oil

Runtime Parse Errors

The way bash works 0x$var can be a hex literal. so var=xx makes this invalid. hex/octal/decimal have this problem.

Parse Time Errors

regcomp() errors (sometimes at parse time; other times at runtime)

Need to show stack trace for "source" like Python. Prototype this.

Also might show which token thing caused you to be in arith parse state, like:

$((echo hi)) ^~ ^~ Arith Invalid token

Generated on Sat Jan 23 00:06:31 PST 2021